Hi,
@darrennewbery + @tjeerd
@darrennewbery You are using version 1.22 of the theme., Please update to 1.4 . If you made modifications to your template files. you can use winmerge.org to directly compare an unmodified version 1.22 to yours and see all your modifications on a character by character basis scanning the entire theme folder at once and comparing.
@tjeerd Please update as well as you are using version 1.11 of the theme while 1.4 is out . If you made modifications to your template files. you can use winmerge.org to directly compare an unmodified version 1.22 to yours and see all your modifications on a character by character basis scanning the entire theme folder at once and comparing.
After updating would you both please install this plugin http://wordpress.org/extend/plugins/wp-paginate/ It allows control over total number of posts/portfolio items etc.. on first page and then a separate value for all additional pages in pagination.
@tjeerd - i see 12 items on your portfolio's first page. Could you lower it to 4, and see if pagination starts working. If it does start increasing until you run into failure. If you get positive result please let us know what the cut off point for number of portfolio items on a page is before pagination breaks.
There are two theories as to why this is happening , so we will examine the easier one first outlined here, even though it deals with categories, the concept is the same. ( http://wordpress.org/support/topic/explanation-and-workaround-for-error-404-on-category-pagination )
Thanks,
Nick
Create a new thread and tell me what problems you are encountering and what you want to know. 
There is no step 3 :) 
